Vanilla Sugar Substitutes: Popular Substitutes and How to Replace

While there are various Vanilla sugar replacements, handmade vanilla sugar and a mix of vanilla extract and sugar are the finest. Vanilla syrup, brown sugar, and maple syrup may all work well, but they all have potential drawbacks to be aware of.

Vanilla sugar is a delicious ingredient that may be used to provide a rich sweetness to baked products and icings. It mixes sweet joy with the rich, subtle undertones of vanilla, often regarded as the most popular taste in the world.

It is often used in European cuisine and is widely available in supermarkets there. However, it is often more difficult to obtain in other parts of the globe, leaving many to question what to use instead.

When a recipe asks for vanilla sugar, it is attempting to do two things at once: sweeten the dish while also imparting a rich and identifiable vanilla flavor. The simple thing is that any alternative will be able to sweeten your food.

The more difficult component of this is achieving the same vanilla taste. The only true equivalent is to produce your own vanilla sugar, since the process of manufacturing the seasoning brings out distinct qualities of flavor, however there are other methods to replicate it.

Substitute 1 – Homemade Vanilla Sugar

If you can’t locate vanilla sugar in the shop, you may manufacture your own out of vanilla beans and regular sugar.

Although the procedure is more complicated than just mixing the two, we advocate crafting your own version if possible rather than merely combining vanilla extract and sugar (though that may still work well).

The procedure is identical to that of manufacturing vanilla extract. In both situations, you’re using the vanilla bean’s inherent ability to infiltrate its flavor into its surroundings.

For every two cups of sugar you wish to infuse, use one vanilla bean. Vanilla beans may be found in many food shops, but they are usually significantly cheaper in bulk if you can locate a source.

You may use whatever kind of sugar you like, so choose one whose taste you want to enjoy in the meal. However, if your recipe asks for powdered vanilla sugar, use powdered sugar.

The real procedure of manufacturing vanilla sugar will begin with the preparation of the beans. Split the beans along their length without penetrating them, then remove the seeds if desired.

The seeds may add additional taste, but they will also give color and texture to the seasoning, which you may not want. On the other hand, if you want to enhance the color and texture of the seeds, extract them from the bean and combine them with the remaining sugar.

Then, combine the bean and sugar in an airtight jar. One bean per container is usually best practice, although it isn’t always necessary.

Make sure the bean is well submerged in the sugar, then store your jar in a cold, dark place to infuse.

After two to five weeks of shaking the containers every few days, you will have homemade vanilla sugar!

Substitute 2 – Vanilla Extract and Sugar

You may not have access to vanilla beans, or you may want to utilize the vanilla sugar sooner than the two weeks it would take to become infused. In such scenario, if you have vanilla essence and some form of granulated sugar on hand, you’ll be OK.

Alternatively, high-quality extract and sugar.While this will not have the same flavor as homemade or store-bought vanilla sugar, it is close enough to make a difference in most meals. Consider using organic and local ingredients to increase the depth of flavor.

To reach the proper proportions, use a teaspoon of vanilla extract and a quarter cup of your preferred sugar for every quarter cup of vanilla sugar called for in the recipe.

This combination is very effective in recipes that ask for vanilla sugar as the only vanilla flavour, such as this Hazelnut Cake. Because there is just one vanilla taste in the meal, the tiny differences between vanilla types are less crucial to consider.

Substitute 3 – Vanilla Syrup

Although not everyone has vanilla extract on hand, many people who love a dose of vanilla in their morning coffee have vanilla syrup on hand and ready to use.

These vanilla syrups may be an ideal alternative for vanilla sugar, but there are several key considerations to keep in mind before doing so.

The first is texture: syrups are always thicker and stickier than granulated or powdered vanilla sugars. If you’re using this in a baked treat, it’s probably best to avoid using vanilla syrup, since it might have unanticipated consequences.

Furthermore, if you are not using homemade syrup, the quality of various store-bought types might vary greatly.

Some are delectable, nuanced ingredients that would enhance any meal, while others taste much more like chemicals than the natural delicacy of vanilla that we were aiming for.

In this regard, vanilla syrup has two outstanding applications. The first is that textural variances across vanilla syrups will be simpler to account for when preparing icing since icing is something you can constantly changing.

This is especially true if the texture of your frosting isn’t important to you.

Substitute 4 – Brown Sugar

With this substitution, we began to stray away from the vanilla-specific taste and toward flavors that achieve the same aims as vanilla without precisely replicating it. That is exactly what brown sugar will accomplish.

Vanilla seldom takes center stage in a meal. Because of its distinct but mild taste, it usually serves as a supporting character, informing and underpinning the interaction of the other flavors without drawing attention to itself.

As a result, while looking for non-vanilla replacements, search for substances that do something comparable without being too difficult to get. Brown sugar is maybe the greatest choice at that point.

Brown sugar’s molasses-y tastes are widely renowned for their ability to infuse depth and richness into the remainder of a meal.

As an added bonus, if you have vanilla extract on hand, you may blend brown sugar with it. The two complement each other really well and will surely elevate your meal to the next level.

Substitute 5 – Maple Syrup

Maple syrup is the ultimate vanilla sugar alternative we suggest. Most of the time, maple syrup is not the ideal option, but it may be all you have on hand.

Because of its consistency, it has more textural issues than other vanilla syrups, and it would, of course, operate as a different taste than vanilla in the dish.

Maple syrup has a very unique taste, and it usually stands out much more than vanilla or molasses in your recipe. However, it is especially handy in recipes that call for vanilla as a major flavor, such as these vanilla bean scones.

Obviously, maple syrup will not replicate the taste of vanilla, but it does play a comparable function to vanilla in these cases: being the focus of attention while influencing all the other flavors that are occurring.

In this sense, maple syrup may be a wonderful substitute for vanilla sugar. It isn’t precisely a substitution since it will affect your food, but because vanilla and maple tastes interact similarly, it may move your dish in a new palate direction without compromising part of its overall excellence.

Other Substitutes for Vanilla Sugar

If none of the solutions described in this article appeal to you, there are still options!

While you are unlikely to find anything else that will work as well to duplicate the vanilla element of vanilla sugar’s taste, there are alternatives such as brown sugar and maple syrup.

For example, we didn’t discuss any other infused sugars in this article, despite the fact that many of them may function as well. This is particularly true for sugars infused with scents that pair nicely with sweet meals, such as cinnamon and nutmeg sugars.

Those other sugar infusions, like vanilla sugar, may function in two ways. You may produce them via a lengthy procedure that extracts unique tastes from natural components (such as entire nutmeg or cinnamon sticks).

You may also make a simple combination by combining a ground variation with your current sugar.


How do I substitute vanilla flavoring?

Vanilla replaces maple syrup. Maple syrup is my go-to vanilla extract alternative.
Extract of almonds. Although almond extract is far more strong than vanilla, it will produce a comparable taste profile if used judiciously.
Rum, Bourbon, or Brandy?
Other seasonings.
Espresso powder or instant coffee.
Zest of citrus.

Can I replace vanilla with anything?

After vanilla, almond extract is one of the most often used extracts in baking. You may use almond extract for vanilla extract in a 1:1 ratio. That is, for every 1 tablespoon (15 mL) of vanilla extract used in the recipe, substitute it with 1 tablespoon (15 mL) of almond extract.

Is vanilla sugar the same as powder sugar?

Granulated vanilla sugar is finest used in frosting, while granulated vanilla sugar is best utilized in baked products.finishing sugar or icing sugarTypically, powdered vanilla sugar is used as a dusting.

What is a healthy substitute for vanilla?

Almond extract is a natural replacement for vanilla, which is another favorite pantry extract. Its nutty undertones would undoubtedly enhance most vanilla flavors; nevertheless, it is far stronger in taste than its mellower version, so decrease the quantity required in the recipe by roughly half.

Can I use maple extract instead of vanilla?

Use half the amount of maple extract as vanilla extract. This works well in pancakes, waffles, french toast, blondies, and oatmeal cookies.

Can I leave vanilla extract out of a recipe?

Remove it.

If you don’t have any of the suggested alternatives, just leave out the vanilla extract and continue with the recipe. There shouldn’t be much of a change in flavor as long as vanilla isn’t the main component.

Can I use sugar instead of vanilla?

Vanilla sugar may be easily substituted with regular granulated sugar at a 1:1 ratio. You may also produce vanilla sugar at home using normal sugar.

What chemical is a substitute for vanilla?

Synthetic vanillin is currently more often utilized as a flavour in foods, drinks, and medications than real vanilla extract.

What to do if you forgot to add vanilla extract?

If you forget to add the vanilla essence, you can always prepare a vanilla flavored glaze and spread it over the warm cake. Repeat the brushings on the cake throughout the next 24 hours to build up a nice layer of flavor.

What is vanilla sugar in baking?

Vanilla sugar is sugar that has been infused with vanilla over time, so it still has that beautiful granular texture that we love in sugar (and need for our perfect baked products! ), but with an extra taste of vanilla for a distinct pop!

Rate this post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *