Substitutes for Halibut

If you’re seeking for a white flesh fish alternative for halibut, you’ll be happy to hear that there are various possibilities, including striped bass, flounder, haddock, and sole.

What is Halibut?

Halibut is the biggest flatfish species, living on the seafloors of the North Pacific, North Atlantic, and Arctic seas. This sweet-tasting, firm-textured fish is a great lean protein that may be baked, fried, grilled, or steamed. They are minimal in fat and calories while being high in protein, selenium, omega-3 fatty acids, Vitamin B, and other minerals.

Moreover, halibut is one of the most costly delicacies on the market, owing to its nutritious value. If you have a meal that calls for halibut but can’t get it at your local grocery, consider using a halibut replacement.

Related: Best Anchovy Substitutes

1. Striped Bass

Striped bass spend the most of their adult life in the ocean and return to freshwater to spawn multiple times. This silver-bellied Atlantic coastal fish is named for the horizontal stripes on its body and may grow to be 16 to 30 inches long and weigh up to 69 pounds.

The texture and look of this variety of bass make it an excellent halibut substitute. It’s a white fish with firm and tender flesh, similar to halibut. But, because of its same leanness, it is more prone to overcooking, therefore keeping an eye on its temperatures is advised.

Striped bass has a mild and sweet taste similar to halibut and lacks the powerful fishy flavor of mackerel or herring, making it a go-to component for recipes calling for halibut steaks.

To make a savory supper, season striped bass with lemon, olive oil, butter, sea salt, or other spices. To increase the nutritional content, serve with a side of sautéed veggies or quinoa.

Striped bass may be cooked in a variety of ways, including baking, broiling, grilling, poaching, and oven or pan-frying.

2. Flounder

Flounder is another fish that may be used in place of halibut. It is another member of the flatfish family, which includes roughly 30 species and may be found at the bottom of the Pacific and Atlantic seas. Its skin might be brown or white, but their flesh is juicy and white.

It’s low in calories and fat, and it’s high in omega-3s, selenium, vitamin D, and vitamin B12. Moreover, because of their flatfish link, many people prefer using flounder as a halibut alternative. Flounder flesh, on the other hand, is more soft than halibut meat, making it unsuitable for cooking.

Flounder has a mild and sweet flavor that is comparable to that of halibut. Its subtlety, on the other hand, enables you to experiment with ingredients to produce a flavor that suits your tastes. Although most filets do not taste fishy, the overall flavor is determined by the kind of flounder utilized.

Moreover, flounder has a flaky texture and flavorfully sweet skin. It keeps its moisture and texture when cooked. Because of its exquisite softness, flounder cannot be grilled; nonetheless, the ideal cooking techniques for flounder preparation are broiling, baking, frying, and poaching. Another thing to think about while cooking it is wrapping it with foil.

When using flounder in a halibut recipe, herbs and lemon juice may improve the taste; meals also perform best when served with a small bowl of vegetables or salad. You may also bread filets before baking or frying them to add flavor.

3. Haddock

Haddock is a cod family member found in the chilly waters of the North Atlantic. They develop quickly, are one to three feet long, and weigh two to seven pounds. They may lay between 850,000 and 3 million eggs per year.

It has a light flavor with a touch of sweetness, much like our other best replacements. It has a delicate but firm texture and is low in fat. Yet, because of its delicate nature, it is prone to overcooking and undercooking, therefore regulating its temperature is vital for optimal cooking.

It’s a great alternative for halibut for baking, frying, poaching, sautéing, or broiling. Yet, because to its low oil content, it is unsuited for grilling and soon dries up when steamed.

Haddock is often served with fish and chips, although it may also be served with roasted vegetables or potatoes. Another fun option to experiment with taste is to add a sprinkle of garlic powder or cayenne pepper for a tangy contrast.

4. Sole

Another flatfish that is comparable to halibut that you might try incorporating in your recipes is sole. The most common variety of sole, often known as the Dover sole, dwells on the sandy seabeds of the Atlantic and Mediterranean oceans. They can grow to be up to 30 inches long and weigh at least 10 pounds.

It has smooth skin and a white underbelly, as well as flesh. It also includes various vitamins and minerals that are essential for your health, including as vitamin B and magnesium.

Many chefs like the mild, sweet, and buttery taste of sole. When cooked with the skin on, its richness rises. It’s a great substitute for halibut if you want to produce recipes that don’t taste too fishy.

Topping sole fish with capers, lemon, or black pepper is a great way to spice up the meal. Baking, steaming, and grilling are the finest techniques for preparing solo meals. It may also be fried with or without its skin.

5. Cod

Cod reside in the cooler waters of the Atlantic Ocean, which runs along the east coast of the United States. They may grow to be about 50 inches long and weigh more than 70 pounds. While they enjoy swimming in cold water during the day, they are active all year and are often encountered during a storm.

Their most noticeable physical characteristics are as follows:

  • Brown or olive skin tone
  • A lateral line runs across their bodies.
  • A barbel under their chin

Because of its comparable sweet and mild flavor and nutritious makeup to halibut, it is one of the most popular fish used in cookery. Cod is often less expensive than halibut, however costs might fluctuate during a good fishing season.

On the side, serve the fish with fresh veggies, coleslaw, or french fries. Adding basil or paprika to your food may make it appear more attractive while also adding a slight taste boost. It’s a fish with a lot of adaptability because to its flaky shell.

From halibut recipes, you may bake, broil, sauté, poach, and fry cod to create a variety of distinct meals. But, due of the tenderness of the flesh, it may be difficult to grill cod, so cook it until the skin is crispy so it doesn’t break apart when turned over on a grilling rack.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Can I Tell if My Fish is Cooked to Its Ideal Temperature?

Your halibut substitute will turn opaque as it cooks. Depending on the kind of fish, the texture grows firmer and flakier.

To verify this, twist a fork at a 45-degree angle and extract chunks of flesh from the thickest part of the fish. Overcooking occurs when the texture gets too firm.

Why Can’t I Put Some Fish on the Grill Like I Do When Cooking Halibut?

Several alternatives to halibut have more delicate skin than halibut. As a consequence, when turned over on a grill, their flesh is more prone to overcooking and breaks apart more quickly. One approach to prevent this is to broil your fish with breadcrumbs.

Should I Buy My Halibut or Substitutions Fresh or Frozen?

But whether you use fresh or frozen fish depends on your cooking choices, the nutrients are the same. But, freezing a fish fillet or steak keeps it fresh for longer periods of time, making it easier to collect your other components without worrying about it rotting rapidly.

Which Nutrients Should I Look For in a Fish Similar to Halibut?

Halibut has a high protein content while being minimal in calories and fat. Consider utilizing a phosphorus, vitamin B12, niacin, vitamin D, and selenium-containing replacement for your recipes. Cod, haddock, and sole are examples of fish with comparable nutritional content.

What Are the Health Benefits of Eating These Fish?

The advantages of eating white fish such as halibut and cod include:

Inflammation control Increasing your immune system’s strength and bone density Keeping your cholesterol in check Any of the fish on this list will provide you with these advantages when eaten.


Halibut is a fantastic main dish for any occasion, but it may not always be accessible or within your price range. While finding a replacement for your recipes may be difficult, it is not impossible.

Various varieties of fish have the same sweet but mild flavor as this flatfish and may be cooked using the same ways. Also, unlike salmon or sardines, they lack a strong fishy taste. Because of their delicate texture, certain fish are especially susceptible to overcooking.

While our top choices share some vitamins and minerals, each one allows you to experiment with various flavors, spices, and sides to make the best-tasting meals for you and your peers.


Is halibut similar to sea bass?

This fantastic Halibut dish combines the natural lightness and mild taste of this fish (which is similar to Sea Bass) with a zesty, fragrant lemon butter sauce with just the proper amount of white wine flavor, as well as a broiler finish for a fantastic crust!

Can you sub tilapia for halibut?

Tilapia fillet may be replaced with Basa, Halibut, Cod, or other white fish.

What is the most similar fish to halibut?

The 5 Greatest Halibut Substitutes
1 – Cod.
Turbot is number two, while haddock is number three.
Flounder (4th).
Dogfish is number five.
Feb 26, 2023

What is a substitute for halibut fillet?

Fluke, flounder, and turbot may be substituted for halibut fillets; wild striped bass or cod can be used for halibut steaks. Halibut is available all year, but it is at its peak between March and September.

What fish is in the same family as halibut?

Most of us are acquainted with soles, flounders, and halibut, but dabs, plaice, brill, tonguefish, and turbot are all distinct sorts of flatfish. They all have one thing in common: they all have both eyes on the same side of their head.

Is mahi-mahi similar to halibut?

Although the flesh texture is similar, halibut is often relatively white, as opposed to the pinkish tint of mahi-mahi. Lastly, although both fish have a moderate taste, mahi-mahi has a more delicate flavor than halibut, with an unique tropical sweetness.

What fish is similar to halibut nutrition?


Its skin might be brown or white, but their flesh is juicy and white. It’s low in calories and fat, and it’s high in omega-3s, selenium, vitamin D, and vitamin B12. Moreover, because of their flatfish link, many people prefer using flounder as a halibut alternative.

Does tilapia taste like halibut?

What Does Halibut Taste Like? Similar to tilapia, this thin fish has mild, sweet-tasting white flesh. It is thicker and more substantial than cod.

Are halibut and cod interchangeable?

Halibut versus cod

Halibut has a solid and hard texture that differs from cod, which is flaky and dense. Many people compare it to cod, but it’s a touch sweeter, harder, and less greasy.

Why is flounder better than halibut?

Given their close relationship, these two fish taste virtually identical to one another. There is one major difference: halibut has more flesh and a firmer texture, while flounder is flakier and more delicate. Additionally, halibut is less fatty than most other fish.

Rate this post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *