Some individuals enjoy goat cheese, while others despise it, like with other foods in the world.

There will always be a goat-cheese skeptic in your family or circle of friends, so it’s a good idea to come up with some goat cheese replacements to satisfy all tastes and nutritional concerns.

In this post, we’ll explain what goat cheese is, why you may need to replace it, and our top five suggestions for the finest goat cheese alternative for all types of goat cheese and their respective meals.

What is Goat Cheese?

Goat cheese is manufactured by curdling goat’s milk, separating the curds, and repeatedly pressing them to obtain the appropriate shape and texture. Goat milk has the ability to be soft and spreadable. It may be matured to become a firm, sliceable cheese. Finally, it might be a crumbly cheese.

Goat cheese comes in as many varieties as cow or sheep milk cheese and may therefore be used as a charcuterie board centerpiece, a salad, soup, or taco topping, and even a dessert element.

Harder goat cheeses are more tangy, and softer, creamier goat cheeses are gentler. However, many goat cheese has a characteristic gamey taste that is also present in goat meat.

In terms of fat content, goat milk and cow milk may be similar. Nonetheless, goat milk contains more caproic, caprylic, and capric fatty acids, which are simpler for humans to digest and are the underlying reason of the gamey, sour flavor that distinguishes it. It is also lower in lactose than cow’s milk.

Goat cheese has less calories than cow or sheep’s milk cheese and is high in healthful saturated fats, probiotics, vitamin B, calcium, and phosphorus.

Recommended Goat Cheese Substitutes

You may use ricotta cheese or blue cheese as alternatives for goat cheese since they have a similar flavor and texture. Mascarpone and tofu cheese are two more options.

1. Sheep or Goat Milk Feta

Feta originated in Greece and is created from curdled sheep milk or a mix of sheep and goat milk, which is then brine-cured for four to six weeks. Feta is the right combination of crumbly, salty, and sour. It is a fantastic goat cheese alternative since it is the closest in texture and taste to goat cheese without the gaminess.

Feta is also the most similar to goat cheese in terms of macronutrient composition, with a high protein and low fat level, making it an excellent alternative for anybody following a low-fat, low-carb diet.

This cheese may be found at any grocery shop. Most supermarkets sell a broad selection of cheeses, including Greek, Bulgarian, French, and American varieties; each kind varies somewhat in creaminess, saltiness, and texture.

Salads, savory tarts and pastries like Spanakopita, spaghetti, and dips like spinach artichoke are the perfect places to utilize Feta instead of goat cheese.

Related Articles:

• Can You Freeze Feta Cheese?
• Common Substitutes for Feta Cheese and How to Replace It

2. Ricotta

Ricotta cheese is an Italian cheese made from leftover whey (one of two proteins contained in milk) from other cheeses that goes through another coagulation process. Ricotta is a fresh cheese made from the whey of cow, goat, sheep, or water buffalo milk. Ricotta is a mild-flavored fresh cheese that is exceptionally creamy, velvety, and rich.

It’s a terrific goat cheese alternative for those who don’t like the strong goat cheese flavor but still want a soft, creamy cheese that’s delicious cold and works well in baking.

Ricotta, in its softer, spreadable forms, is a suitable alternative for goat cheese. Ricotta may be used in both sweet and savory meals, and it goes well with honey and fruit on a cheese platter. It has achieved worldwide recognition and is as widely available as goat or feta cheese.

Stuffed shells, manicotti, pizza, soup topping or thickening, and cheesecakes are the most prominent uses for ricotta.

Related Article: Ricotta Cheese Substitutes

3. Blue Cheese

Blue cheese is one of the oldest types of cheese and hence comes in a variety of shapes and sizes, the most popular of which being Roquefort and Gorgonzola. The mold culture Penicillium is added to milk while it develops curds or straight to the curds themselves to make blue cheese. Blue cheese is available in cow, goat, and sheep milk varieties, with the distinguishing feature being the Penicillium culture, which produces the striking blue veins for which it is known.

Blue cheese may be soft and crumbly or firm, but it has a strong odor and taste that is similar to goat cheese. Blue cheese is also a highly nutritious cheese that is beneficial to gut health, visceral fat reduction, and heart disease prevention.

Blue cheese is available in a variety of flavors at your local grocery store and cheese shop. Because of the powerful taste, a little goes a long way. It goes well with dried fruit, apples, pears, and candied nuts in salads or on toast. It’s also a tasty pizza and spaghetti topping.

4. Mascarpone

Mascarpone cheese is another exquisite but basic Italian cheese. Cream is coagulated with citric acid, lemon juice, or vinegar to make it. As a result, it is similar to cream cheese but without the acidity.

Mascarpone is a creamy soft goat cheese substitute that compensates for its mild taste. It’s available at most supermarket shops. It is the sweetest of the cheese alternatives on our list. It may be used in place of full-fat yogurt, topped with fruit and honey, and eaten with a spoon. Mascarpone is also used in Italian sweets such as Cannoli and Tiramisu, and it is a crucial component in cake icing.

Because it is bland, you may flavor it with salty or sour ingredients and use it in a variety of pasta dishes, risottos, and sauces.

5. Tofu

Tofu is the greatest alternative for goat cheese for lactose intolerant, non-dairy eaters, and vegans. Tofu, also known as bean curd, is coagulated soy milk. As coagulated curds of milk may be further pressed to create the required texture, it goes through a similar procedure as cheese.

Tofu, like cheese, has a high fat and protein content, but unlike cheese, it is cholesterol-free.

You may purchase tofu in a variety of textures at your local grocery shop. Tofu packaging often categorizes tofu by hardness, with four options available: Silken, Soft, Firm, and Super Firm.

Tofu has a neutral taste that absorbs any flavor that is marinated, baked, or sautéed with it. To ensure that the tofu absorbs and keeps the intended tastes or spices, remove any excess water from both the container and the tofu. Wrap the drained block of tofu in a kitchen towel and place a heavy plate on top for 15-30 minutes to properly dry it out and absorb marinades, flavorings, and oils.

Tofu has varied degrees of hardness, so if you want a crumbly goat cheese substitute, break up firm or extra firm tofu and blend it with cheesy ingredients like nutritional yeast or garlic salt.

If you want a spreadable or creamy vegan equivalent for goat cheese, however, use exceptionally soft, silken tofu. In a blender or food processor, combine silken tofu with salty or sweet ingredients to spread over crackers and toast or use in cheesecakes, tarts, or pies.

Why Would You Need to Substitute Goat Cheese?

There are several instances and reasons to utilize a goat cheese alternative. First and foremost, it has a particular taste that many people dislike. Goat milk, goat cheese, and goat meat all have an identifiable and powerful gaminess about them.

Another cause might be a goat milk or meat allergy, for which there are many of cow and sheep milk replacements with comparable textures, protein to fat ratios, and taste profiles.

A third explanation might simply be a lack of the sort of goat cheese specified in the recipe. You may arrive at your local grocery shop to discover that they are out of stock or do not carry the goat cheese you want, and you may not have the time to explore elsewhere. As a result, it’s always a good idea to keep a few goat cheese substitutes on hand.

The third reason you may need to replace goat cheese is if you are lactose sensitive or vegan and cannot consume dairy products. It is usually more difficult to discover alternatives that contain the texture, nutritional makeup, and taste profile of dairy products; yet, it is not impossible.

Final Thoughts

You should now have plenty of alternatives for any last-minute changes to your dinner arrangements. While not everyone like goat cheese, virtually everyone may find a favorite among the goat cheese replacements mentioned above.

More on Cheese Substitute:

• Best Substitutes For Farmers Cheese
• The Best Substitutes for Taleggio Cheese
• The Best Substitutes for Gouda Cheese