Best Brand of Store-Bought Cocktail Sauce

Cocktail sauce’s spicy and acidic tastes are a mainstay for shrimp and shellfish, whether you’re sitting around at home or organizing a lavish dinner party. And you’re not alone. Cocktail sauce consumption has increased by over 84% since August 2019, according to Tastewise. So you may be asking, which cocktail sauce brand is the best?

In this post, we’ll discuss our five favorite cocktail sauce brands, emphasizing each one’s distinct qualities.

Best Cocktail Sauce Brand Reviews

1. Old Original Bookbinder Cocktail Sauce

Old Original Bookbinder Cocktail Sauce
Old Original Bookbinder was a restaurant in Philadelphia established in 1865. The store closed in 2009 as a result of the recession. But thanks to a food division the Taxin family started in the 1970s, it’s still possible for families across the country to enjoy Old Original Bookbinder’s classic cocktail sauce.
Check Price

The 32-ounce jar weights 2.25 pounds and is ideal for big families and gatherings. Old Original Bookbinder’s mild to medium cocktail sauce combines just the proper amount of fresh horseradish and spices to give the sauce a little bite without making it overly hot on the tongue.

In terms of price, Old Original Bookbinders cocktail sauce falls somewhere in the center. It isn’t the cheapest cocktail sauce on the market, but there are plenty of more expensive (and smaller) jars available.

While Sams Club no longer offers it, Old Original Bookbinders cocktail sauce is available at numerous grocery shops throughout the United States. Lovers of Old Original Bookbinder, on the other hand, should rest comfortable since it is still readily available for purchase on websites such as Amazon.

Highlights of the Old Original Bookbinder:

  • Fresh horseradish is used.
  • It was founded in 1865.
  • Kosher certification

2. St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail Sauce

St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail Sauce
St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail Sauce is another cocktail sauce derived from an American restaurant. The St. Elmo Steak House was founded in Indiana in 1902. Upon the request of countless customers, they launched their cocktail sauce into retail grocery stores.
Check Price

Extremely Hot is the label on the 12-ounce, 1.5-pound container of St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail Sauce. Lovers of this cocktail sauce joke that you need be prepared with a fire extinguisher. You would, however, have to be fast. In a little while, the burning sensation subsides.

To keep the spicy taste of their cocktail sauce, St. Elmo suggests keeping it in the refrigerator. Also, this is the ideal method for any cocktail sauce.

St. Elmo stands out for manufacturing cocktail sauce without high-fructose corn syrup, making it thick and gluten-free.

Saint. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail Sauce is distinguished by its pairing with St. Elmo Steak House Spice. Season meat, fish, and vegetables with this tasty bottle. St. Elmos seasoning, like the cocktail sauce, is Kosher and gluten-free.

St. Elmo’s cocktail sauce is packaged in an appealing, rustic-style appearance. As a result, it’s an ideal present for spicy cocktail sauce fans.

The pricing of St. Elmo Shrimp Elmo Cocktail Sauce is on the upper end of the shrimp cocktail price range. But, one must realize that it also includes St. Elmos’ delectable steak house spice.

St. Elmo is the best option if you want a powerful taste with the sharpest horseradish spice you’ve ever experienced in a cocktail sauce. Don’t be shocked if you get hooked!

Depending on where you live, you can get St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail Sauce at Costco, Target, Whole Foods, and Kroger. If your local grocer does not have it, don’t worry; you can get it online and have it brought to you anywhere in the world.

The following are the standout characteristics of St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail Sauce:

  • Strong horseradish taste with a lot of heat
  • Gluten-free
  • There is no high-fructose corn syrup.
  • St. Elmos Steak House Seasoning is included in the price.

3. Johnny’s French Cocktail Sauce

Johnny’s French Cocktail Sauce
When thinking about the best cocktail sauce brand, Johnny’s French Cocktail Sauce might not be at the forefront of your mind. Why’s that, you ask? Because Johnny’s French Cocktail Sauce is technically an au jus.
Check Price

The phrase “au jus” means “with juice” in French. Au jus is a broad word for the use of broth or sauces to enhance the taste of meats and vegetables. Cocktail sauce, on the other hand, adds a kick to foods.

Johnny’s French Cocktail Sauce has its origins in Seattle. Johnny Meaker launched Crawfords Sea Grill in 1940 after much trial and error exploring various spice combinations. Johnny went on to fine-tune his cocktail sauce into the popular au jus available today, aided by rave customer evaluations.

Cocktail sauces are used for more than just shrimp and shellfish, as you’ll see in our FAQ section. Using cocktail sauce with meatloaf, for example, is a terrific way to enhance flavor. Johnny’s French Cocktail Sauce is a great option for this kind of cuisine.

Johnnys French Cocktail Sauce is available in a concentrated version. If you want to use it as a dip, pour it into a container and serve it like you would any standard cocktail sauce. Instead, dilute it with water and drizzle it over meat and veggies.

It comes in an 8-ounce jar and is priced similarly to Old Original Bookbinders cocktail sauce, but don’t be fooled by its smaller size. This little bottle will last you a long time since the concentrated sauce may be diluted and used in a variety of ways.

Johnnys French Cocktail Sauce has the following distinguishing features:

  • It has a beefy taste that makes it an ideal cocktail sauce for meat.
  • Johnny’s Seattle restaurant created this dish.
  • Ingredients such as red wine vinegar and tomato paste are used.

4. Stonewall Kitchen Cocktail Sauce

Stonewall Kitchen Cocktail Sauce
Stonewall Kitchen is a recognized brand across the United States and abroad. As such, it’s the best store bought cocktail sauce due to its accessibility. You’ll have access to Stonewall Kitchen Cocktail Sauce in over 6,000 stores across the globe.
Check Price

Stonewall Kitchen Cocktail Sauce’s components stand out from the rest of the list. They utilize fresh California tomatoes that have matured on the vine. Without using high-fructose corn syrup, agave nectar and cane sugar provide a hint of sweetness. Those who are allergic to seafood should be aware that it contains anchovies.

Stonewall Kitchen Cocktail Sauce is gluten-free and created entirely in the United States. It’s perfect for folks who want a little sweetness in their cocktail sauce rather than a lot of heat from horseradish. Because of its California tomatoes, it tends to err on the side of tomato flavor.

Stonewall Kitchens New England Cocktail Sauce comes in a lovely glass container and is the most affordable cocktail sauce choice on our list, at 8.75 ounces. It’s a terrific alternative for the family dinner table or for a gourmet present that seems more expensive than it is.

If you still need persuading, Stonewall Kitchen has earned 28 Specialty Food Association honors, including three for Best Product Line. The firm has only been in operation since 1991, yet they have achieved significant progress from their humble beginnings at local farmers markets.

Stonewall Kitchen Cocktail Sauce has the following distinguishing characteristics:

  • Gourmet product created in the United States
  • Prepared with fresh California vine-ripened tomatoes
  • Gluten-free
  • Award-winning company

5. Crosse & Blackwell Cocktail Sauce

Crosse & Blackwell Cocktail Sauce
Crosse & Blackwell is a British company established in 1706, making it the oldest cocktail sauce brand on this list. It’s famous for its pub-style sauces and is now part of the world-renown J.M. Smucker Company.
Check Price

Cocktail Sauce by Crosse & Blackwell is great for those seeking for a moderate, multi-purpose sauce. It goes well with shrimp and other shellfish. Yet, because of the rich tomato basis, it makes an excellent dip for french fries and onion rings.

While the tomatoes give this sauce a sweeter taste, it isn’t without a little bite. Your sinuses will be clean thanks to a dash of horseradish. Nonetheless, the experience is brief, making it ideal for individuals who want to avoid spicy sauces.

Tamarind, a sour pulp surrounding seeds that grows on trees in Africa and other tropical places, is a distinctive component in Crosse & Blackwell Cocktail Sauce. Typically, it is combined with a little of sugar, which is also included in this cocktail sauce, contributing to the original Crosse & Blackwell Cocktail Sauce taste.

Crosse & Blackwell’s cocktail sauce comes in a 12-ounce glass container. It’s on the expensive side for cocktail sauces, but any fan will tell you it’s worth the additional money.

Highlights of Crosse & Blackwell Cocktail Sauce:

  • It’s versatile enough to go with dishes like french fries and onion rings.
  • Moderate tomato taste with a horseradish undertone
  • Parve kosher

Cocktail Sauce FAQs

Now that we’ve reviewed the companies that make the finest cocktail sauce for shrimp, let’s take a look at some frequently asked cocktail sauce questions.

Does cocktail sauce go bad?

Cocktail sauce may spoil, so be sure to check the expiry date. Cocktail sauce containers that have not been opened do not need to be refrigerated, but they must be kept out of direct sunlight. Once opened, the cocktail sauce should be refrigerated to keep it from becoming rancid.

How long does shrimp cocktail sauce last in the fridge?

An opened can of shrimp cocktail sauce will keep in the fridge for six to nine months. An unopened can of cocktail sauce does not need to be refrigerated. Keep in mind that the longer a jar of cocktail sauce sits open, the more likely it is to lose taste.

How long does cocktail sauce last once opened if not refrigerated?

Without refrigeration, a can of cocktail sauce may survive anywhere from a few days to up to a month. Still, keep your unrefrigerated cocktail sauce in a well sealed container and away from direct sunlight.

Can you eat cocktail sauce after the expiration date?

Cocktail sauce jars, like most foods, have an overestimated expiry date. As a result, you should understand what to look for to determine whether your cocktail sauce is bad. The following are indications that your cocktail sauce should be tossed: rotten odor Specks of white or fluff on the surface, indicating mold Poor taste It is crucial to remember that a gel consistency does not imply that your cocktail sauce is bad.

With what can you pair cocktail sauce?

Cocktail sauce is most typically served with shrimp, but it has many other applications for creative chefs. Cocktail sauces go well with fried seafood, meatloaf, oysters, fish cakes, and even chili and Bloody Marys.

What are the main ingredients in cocktail sauces?

Cocktail sauce’s key components include horseradish, ketchup, Worcestershire sauce, lemon, and Tabasco sauce. Other kinds, however, contain hints of other ingredients for a distinct flavor. Onion, garlic, and cloves are among examples.

What makes cocktail sauce spicy?

Tabasco sauce and horseradish are two elements that add to the fiery, scorching taste of cocktail sauce. Horseradish is a root vegetable that is popular for its sinus-clearing properties due to its ability to enhance face circulation.

Wrap Up

Selecting the finest cocktail sauce is a matter of taste. Those who like the peppery flavor of horseradish will enjoy the St. Elmo and Old Original Bookbinders brands.

Those who like a sweeter flavor may choose Stonewall Kitchen and Crosse & Blackwells cocktail sauces. Finally, Johnnys French Cocktail Sauce will amaze anybody searching for a meaty infusion.

Whichever cocktail sauce you pick, you can be certain that those on this list will improve the flavor of your dish and make everyone happy.

Related Posts:

  • Best Enchilada Sauce in a Can
  • Horseradish Sauce Manufacturers with the Best Reviews
  • Best Pre-Purchased Pizza Sauce
  • Reviews of the Best Soy Sauce
  • The 5 Best Store-Bought Teriyaki Sauces


Should Heinz cocktail sauce be refrigerated?

Shelf Life Suggestions

When kept in the pantry, opened cocktail sauce will normally keep for 1 month. Refrigerate opened cocktail sauce to increase its shelf life.

What is a fancy name for cocktail sauce?

Cocktail sauce, often known as seafood sauce, is one of numerous cold or room temperature sauces that are frequently offered as part of a shrimp cocktail or as a condiment with other seafoods.

Is Crosse & Blackwell cocktail sauce discontinued?

J.M. Smucker Corporation withdrew the Crosse & Blackwell brand in December 2022, with goods no longer produced for North America.

Why does cocktail sauce taste so good?

The freshness of the ingredients and the mixing is what makes them magical. Indeed, you use store-bought ketchup, but the Worcestershire sauce and lemon give depth of flavor and a sharp acidic punch. All of the typical tastes of cocktail sauce are enhanced by the horseradish.

How long does an open jar of cocktail sauce last in the fridge?

Refrigerate condiments after opening for the following times: ketchup, cocktail sauce, or hot chili sauce Six months. 1 to 2 months for chutney. 3 to 4 months for horseradish.

Should mayonnaise be refrigerated?

Mayonnaise. Mayonnaise may be purchased on a non-refrigerated shelf, however it must be refrigerated as soon as the cap is removed. In fact, the USDA advises that unsealed mayonnaise be discarded if its temperature rises to 50 degrees or higher for more than eight hours.

Is a type of sauce that is good for cocktail appetizers?

Cocktail sauce is a chilled dip that is served with shrimp cocktail. Ketchup, prepared horseradish, Worcestershire sauce, Tabasco, and lemon juice are common ingredients in the American version. If you like something hotter, replace the ketchup with a tomato-based chili sauce.

Is cocktail sauce made of ketchup and horseradish?

A sweet dipping sauce mixed with ketchup, horseradish, and herbs that is ideal for dipping shrimp or other kinds of seafood.

What is the difference ketchup cocktail sauce?

By the way, what’s the difference between ketchup and cocktail sauce? Coe, Nick: Not a lot. Chili sauce, which is a form of ketchup with extra peppers, is the most basic cocktail sauce… The horseradish, Worcestershire sauce, and lemon juice are then added.

Does Heinz make cocktail sauce?

Heinz Cocktail Sauce offers a premium flavor that’s the perfect compliment to your shrimp, thanks to the best quality ingredients and an optimal combination of spices. Our thick, powerful cocktail sauce adheres to your shrimp flawlessly, leaving an enticing scent and a great taste you’re sure to enjoy!

Rate this post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *