Almond butter’s nutty deliciousness has made its way into a variety of dishes, but it is not for everyone. Almond butter cannot be used in recipes by those who have nut allergies or dislike the flavor of almonds. Almond butter is also pricey and not widely accessible in certain locations.

Whatever your reason for avoiding almond butter, almond butter substitutes may be used in its place. Each provides comparable health advantages to almond butter as well as the fats required for baking.

Each of these five almond butter substitutes is a baking replacement for almond butter that also has healthful fats and taste. These ingredients may also provide a pleasant taste to muffins, quick breads, cakes, and other baked goods.

Top 5 Almond Butter Alternatives

These almond butter substitutes provide bakers with additional choices when preparing recipes that call for almond butter. Each of these almond butter substitutes works well in a range of recipes, and some of them are less costly than almond butter. The majority of these almond butter replacements are simply accessible in any store.

Peanut Butter

If almond butter is too pricey or difficult to come by, try using peanut butter instead. Peanut butter complements chocolate beautifully in most dessert recipes and is inexpensive. This almond butter substitute is widely accessible and is most likely present in most kitchen pantries.

Those who dislike the flavor and texture of almonds may find peanut butter to be a tasty substitute. Peanut butter may evoke childhood memories of eating peanut butter and jelly sandwiches and discovering peanut butter cups in Halloween candy.

Peanut butter has a texture comparable to almond butter, making it an easy almond butter substitute. If your recipe asks for almond butter, replace it with an equivalent quantity of peanut butter. Because they are so similar, you may anticipate peanut butter melting and coating dry ingredients in the same manner that almond butter does.

Peanut butter is high in protein and has several health advantages. Because peanut butter has little carbs, it is a common addition in meal replacement bars and smoothies. Peanut butter has no cholesterol since it is made from plants. Peanut butter is strong in healthful fats, so it keeps you full.

For a quick breakfast that will last until noon, swirl peanut butter into a cup of oats. Smoothies, cookie dough, muffins, bread, and Thai cookery all benefit from the inclusion of peanut butter.

Peanut butter may not be suitable for little children or people who are allergic to peanuts.

Cashew Butter

Cashew butter is more expensive than almond butter, but since it has a comparable texture, it works well as an almond butter substitute in baking.

If you prefer the rich flavor of cashews, cashew butter may be a tasty replacement for almond butter in baking. Cashew butter may also be turned into a delectable fudge. Use cashew butter as a 1:1 substitution for almond butter, which means that if your recipe calls for a cup of almond butter, use a cup of cashew butter instead.

Because cashew butter contains more monounsaturated fat than almond butter, it has a creamier taste than other nut butters. This almond butter substitute has less protein than almond butter or peanut butter, both of which have 25% protein.

Cashews and cashew butter lack Omega-3 fatty acids found in other nuts. Unsalted cashew butter is essentially sodium-free and cholesterol-free. Because a serving of cashew butter contains roughly 12% of the daily fat requirement, use it sparingly as an almond butter substitute.

With rich, delectable results, cashew butter may be substituted for almond butter in dishes such as chocolate chip cookies and brownies.

Mashed Avocado

Nut butters are not suitable for anyone who are allergic to nuts. The good news is that those who are allergic to nuts may still enjoy recipes that call for almond butter since mashed avocado can be used as an almond butter substitute.

Think again if you thought avocado was just for guacamole. Avocado’s creamy texture is excellent on toast, but it may also lend richness to baked dishes. Vegans often use mashed avocado for butter in baked dishes, and it may also serve as an almond butter substitute.

Avocados have more good fats and less calories than almond butter, so dieters like this almond butter substitute. A Penn State research discovered that eating an avocado every day lowers LDL cholesterol, the harmful cholesterol that cardiologists warn patients about.

Mashed avocado may be used in place of almond butter in baking in a 1:1 ratio, but since avocado does not melt like nut butter, you may need to add wet ingredients to get the proper consistency in cake and brownie mixes.

Avocado lends a rich, creamy texture without overpowering taste to delectable sweets like chocolate mousse, chocolate pudding, and key lime pie. Blended avocado adds creaminess and healthy fats to smoothies.

Mashed Banana

If the thought of mashed banana makes you think of warm banana nut bread, you already know how amazing bananas can be in baking. Mashed banana may be used as an almond butter replacement for individuals who are allergic to nuts, as well as a butter substitute in vegan baking.

When using mashed banana as an almond butter substitute, use soft, extremely ripe bananas. In a 1:1 ratio, mashed bananas may be used in place of almond butter. Consider how tasty mashed bananas would be in brownies or quick breads.

Bananas, technically a berry, are a guilt-free almond butter substitute for baking. According to research, bananas are high in soluble fiber, which may help reduce blood sugar levels. They have no fat and roughly 112 calories per banana. Bananas are abundant in potassium, which is good for your heart.

Another advantage of baking with mashed bananas is that your home will smell fantastic. Banana cakes, muffins, pancakes, and quick breads are low in fat but high in flavor. Smoothies with bananas provide additional potassium and a tropical taste boost.

Greek Yogurt

Using Greek yogurt instead of almond butter adds protein to baked products while also imparting a rich, creamy taste. Greek yogurt is another almond butter substitute for people who cannot use nut butters in baking owing to nut allergies; however, since Greek yogurt is a dairy product, it is not suitable for vegan baking.

Using Greek yogurt in baking reduces fat and calories while increasing protein content. 1 tablespoon Greek yogurt may be substituted for each tablespoon of almond butter called for in a recipe. A benefit of using Greek yogurt as an almond butter substitute is that it imparts a tangy taste comparable to buttermilk in baked products.

For individuals managing their sodium intake, Greek yogurt provides half the sodium of ordinary yogurt and double the protein. Greek yogurt has less carbs than conventional yogurt because it contains less lactose, making it simpler to digest.

Because Greek yogurt comes in plain, sweetened, and flavored forms, use unsweetened plain yogurt to avoid taste clashes with other ingredients in your dish. To add additional flavor to quick breads and muffins, use lemon, strawberry, or blueberry kinds of Greek yogurt.

Greek yogurt is extremely wonderful when combined with fruit and oats for breakfast, snacks, or desserts. Greek yogurt may also be used as a basis for a healthier version of cheesecake or as a protein and calcium-rich smoothie component.

FAQs About Almond Butter Alternatives

These commonly asked questions regarding almond butter replacements may help to address any more queries about almond butter substitutes.

Can almond butter be unhealthy?

While almond butter offers many health advantages, almond butter with additional sugar or oils may add extra calories and bad fats.

Before purchasing almond butter, peanut butter, or cashew butter, check the ingredients list. Also, people who are allergic to peanuts or tree nuts should avoid almond butter, peanut butter, and cashew butter.

What are the advantages of almond butter alternatives?

Almond butter is one of the more costly nut butters, therefore it may not be widely accessible.

Some bakers may be seeking for low-fat, low-calorie almond butter alternatives. Others are unable to consume almond butter due to allergies. For these reasons, almond butter substitutes might be beneficial to your pantry.

Are all almond butter alternatives lower in calories?

Although almond butter is abundant in nutrients, it may also be heavy in calories. Some almond butter substitutes, such as banana, are fewer in calories, while nut butters contain comparable calories to almond butter.