Allspice Substitute: Common Substitutes and How to Replace

Allspice is a popular spice that can be found in practically any grocery shop and almost every kitchen cabinet in America.

But what if you’re out of them and don’t have time to go out and get more? What can you use in place of allspice? Cloves, nutmeg, and cinnamon are among the greatest, but we’ll go through a few more below.

The name of this spice might be deceiving; in fact, there’s a strong possibility you don’t even know what it is. Although the name implies that allspice is a spice combination, it is really simply one spice.

The spice is derived from a berry on the myrtle pepper tree, often known as the pimento tree. It grows in Central America and Jamaica, and the dried berries are pulverized into a fine powder that you can purchase easily packed in the baking section.

Allspice contains just one spice, yet it is a highly versatile ingredient that may be used in a variety of dishes. It has a sweet and toasty taste profile that many associate with pepper, cinnamon, clove, and nutmeg.

When it’s time to create a dessert-like pie, cake, or muffins, use allspice. However, it may also be found in savory recipes like soups and stews. It doesn’t end there. Everything from jerky and sausage to marinades and dry rubs may be made using allspice.

After all of this, let us now discuss the replacements that can rescue the day.

Allspice is a delicious and healthful spice that may be used in a variety of cuisines. Not only is one serving merely five calories, but it is also loaded with health benefits such as:

  • Reducing inflammation
  • Treating nausea
  • Preventing infection
  • Relieving pain
  • Easing menopause symptoms

Allspice is a low-calorie ingredient that is also low in carbohydrates and high in potassium, calcium, manganese, iron, and vitamin B5.

Allspice is another interesting spice to keep whole. You may keep the dried berries in sealed containers for a long time and crack or grind them whenever you need them. Every time, you’ll get a new, strong taste.

It’s not as easy to use as ground allspice, but it’s definitely worth it.

Unfortunately, we have all been in the scenario when we have prepared everything for a dish only to discover that we are missing one vital ingredient. Allspice is the ingredient of the day.

Check out our list of the best five allspice substitutes below.


You can’t get much better than cloves as an allspice berry alternative. Cloves and allspice berries have extremely similar taste characteristics.

They’re both incredibly powerful in flavor and perfume, with a warm spiciness that you can nearly feel in your toes.

Cloves vary in various ways, which is crucial to remember if you want to use them as an allspice alternative.

Cloves have a sweeter taste than allspice, which has a spicy flavor. Allspice is somewhat more potent than cloves due to its spicy undertone. Nonetheless, in a pinch, they are an excellent substitute.

Cloves are also an excellent substitute for ground allspice since they are available in powder form.

Cloves may somewhat alter the taste of your food, but a one-to-one substitution is usually OK. If you’re worried that the cloves may make your meal excessively sweet, add them gradually and taste as you go.


Nutmeg is another spice that tastes just like allspice. These two components are derived from evergreen plants.

Nutmeg originates from the nutmeg tree, which is simple to remember! This tree is native to Indonesia, as opposed to the origin of allspice.

Although nutmeg has a taste profile that is quite similar to allspice, it is nuttier. Given the name of the tree and the spice, this should come as no surprise.

Although it lacks the spicy undertones of allspice, its taste may offer a wonderful touch to baked goods, punches, and salad dressings.

Start with a one-to-two recipe when substituting nutmeg for allspice. Rather of using the whole quantity of allspice, start with half and taste the meal. You may always add more, but it is very tough to remove.

Some of you may like to add a pinch of pepper in addition to the nutmeg. This may assist to more precisely simulate the flavor of the allspice for a more realistic match.

Nutmeg is available as a powder and has a similar color as allspice, so it will not alter the texture or look of your meal.


If you don’t have cloves or nutmeg but still need a ground allspice replacement, cinnamon may be used. Cinnamon is maybe more prevalent than the first two spices we listed, so you most certainly have a jar of it in your pantry.

Cinnamon is derived from a plant known as the cinnamon tree. We’ve all seen cinnamon sticks in the spice store or in winter crafts, right? Those sticks are really bits of the tree’s bark that have been rolled, chopped, and packed for your convenience.

In most circumstances, baking and cooking using cinnamon powder makes more sense. The fine texture is ideal for cookies, cakes, rolls, muffins, and other baked goods, but it may also be used in sauces and other savory recipes.

Cinnamon isn’t the best substitution for allspice, which is one of the possibilities above, but it works very well in a pinch. Cinnamon lacks the peppery allspice’s bite but has the same spicy, toasty taste character.

Keep in mind that it is sweeter and gentler, so keep that in mind while substituting it.

If you want to attempt to get a closer match to allspice with cinnamon, combine it with nutmeg and a sprinkle of pepper. Your recipe’s texture and color will stay unchanged.

Pumpkin Spice

What about pumpkin spice? That’s correct, this spice is more than simply a seasonal favorite. Pumpkin spice is helpful and welcome all year long in cooking and baking, and it has more applications than you may expect.

If you are genuinely at a loss and are unable to get any of the spices suggested so far, you may utilize pumpkin spice as a last option.

When using pumpkin spice in a baking recipe, it works best. With adding pumpkin spice in the mix, almost any baking recipe, whether bread, cupcakes, or cookies, will taste fantastic.

What you may not know about pumpkin spice is that it does not include anything from a pumpkin. It even has allspice in it! This seasonal favorite taste is enhanced with allspice, ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves.

Even in the midst of summer, pumpkin spice is easily accessible at any grocery shop. You don’t have to wait until October to get your hands on it, and it’s always an excellent spice to have on hand.

When using pumpkin spice as an allspice substitute, use a one-to-one ratio. Because pumpkin spice is sweeter, you may need to add only a touch of pepper to attain the same taste.

Spice Blend

Despite the fact that allspice is derived from a single allspice berry, it turns out that you can make your own allspice mix by combining a handful of the spices on our list.

We have established that allspice has a complex taste profile with undertones of nutmeg, cloves, and cinnamon. If that’s what you get when you sample the spice, why not reproduce it with those ingredients?

Combine nutmeg, ground clove, and ground cinnamon in equal proportions. This lovely combination will look, smell, and taste virtually like to allspice, making it an almost ideal alternative.

In certain circumstances, a dash of pepper may be added to the mix, however the clove flavor may be plenty for your cuisine.

If you want to make this mix even more enjoyable, obtain all of the components fresh and whole and ground them yourself. For a classic, hands-on feel, ground cinnamon sticks, cloves, and nutmegs with a mortar and pestle.

A coffee bean grinder, food processor, or specialty spice grinder may also be used for a speedier, more effective technique, yet nothing beats the mortar and pestle.

Add your ingredients to any kind of grinder and grind for around 30 seconds. Check the fineness of the spices and grind for another 10 seconds, testing the consistency as you go.

Replace allspice in almost every recipe that calls for this earthy ingredient with a one-to-one ratio of your spice mix.


What can I use if I don’t have allspice?

While allspice is not a blend, it is relatively simple to make a similar-tasting combination using spices you already have in your home. 312 teaspoons ground cinnamon, 114 teaspoons ground nutmeg, and a sprinkle of ground cloves whisked together, then used as a 1:1 substitute for ground allspice in a recipe.

What spices are similar to allspice?

Cloves, cinnamon, and nutmeg.

You can develop a spice blend that tastes quite similar to allspice. For every 1 teaspoon allspice, substitute the following: What exactly is this? If you don’t have either, use 34 teaspoon cinnamon with 14 teaspoon nutmeg or 34 teaspoon cinnamon with 14 teaspoon cloves.

What is a substitute for 1 teaspoon of allspice?

2 teaspoon ground cloves, and a sprinkle of ground nutmeg. More information and culinary advice about spices may be found in our Spice Guide.1 teaspoon cinnamon powder1 teaspoon allspice may be substituted for 1 teaspoon allspice.

Can I use all purpose seasoning instead of allspice?

Is it the same thing? No, don’t be misled by the names; they are not the same thing. Allspice is a single spice, while all-purpose seasoning is a spice combination. Allspice is made from berries and has a distinct taste.

What does allspice do in a recipe?

WHAT IS THE PURPOSE OF ALLSPICE? Allspice may be used in a range of sweet and savory dishes, including cookies, pumpkin pie, spice cake, sausage spicing, and ham glazes. It’s a vital ingredient in Jamaican jerk seasoning, a hot combination of herbs and spices that instantly transforms chicken or pig into a party.

What is the flavor of allspice?

So, how does allspice taste? Because the taste profile is multifaceted, with notes of cloves, nutmeg, star anise, fennel, black pepper, and cinnamon, it’s no surprise that allspice is sometimes misidentified as Chinese five-spice or pumpkin spice.

Can you substitute nutmeg for allspice?

Because allspice is widely accessible in kitchen cabinets, it is a practical substitute for nutmeg. In your recipes, substitute nutmeg with an equal quantity of allspice. Ground berries from the Pimenta dioica tree are used to make allspice. It has a similar taste to nutmeg and may be substituted in a 1:1 ratio.

Is cinnamon and allspice the same?

Because it tastes similar to cinnamon, allspice may be used in lieu of cinnamon in most recipes. However, since allspice is more strong than cinnamon, use just a quarter or a third of the quantity of allspice specified in the recipe for cinnamon.

What is allspice compared to mixed spice?

Allspice is more earthy and peppery than mixed spice. What exactly is allspice? The number of spices used is one evident distinction between mixed spice and allspice. Contrary to its name, allspice is just one variety of berry endemic to the Caribbean and Central America.

What is in McCormick allspice?

We ground real allspice berries that have been hand-picked for their peppery sweetness and spicy scent at McCormick. Allspice combines the sweet and spicy tastes of three spice rack standbys: cloves, cinnamon, and nutmeg.

Rate this post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *