5 Similar Substitutes for Parmesan Cheese (Diary & Non-Diary)

Parmesan cheese is a common ingredient in Italian cuisine. If you can’t find this delectable cheese, or if you just want to try something new, there are a few parmesan cheese substitutes that will work just as well.

We’ve limited it down to five parmesan cheese substitutes for your convenience: Asiago, Romano, Pecorino Romano, Grana Padano, and nutritional yeast.

The rough, crumbly texture and strong taste of parmesan cheese contribute to its delectability. So, if you need to substitute parmesan cheese in a dish, you must locate something with a comparable taste and texture. Fortunately, all of the replacements on this list are quite similar in texture and flavor.

Here are five alternatives to parmesan cheese:

  • Asiago cheese
  • Romano cheese
  • Nutritional yeast
  • Pecorino romano
  • Grana padano

Asiago Cheese: Best Substitute for Parmesan Cheese

Aged asiago cheese has a mellow, nutty taste comparable to parmesan cheese. It comes in a variety of sharpness and hardness degrees, which fluctuate based on its age.

The maturing process is what gives asiago cheese its flaky texture and strong flavor, so if you want a taste similar to parmesan, go for asiago that has been matured for roughly nine months.

Because it has a milder taste than parmesan, you may need to use more asiago cheese in your recipes when substituting it for parmesan. Fortunately, it is usually reasonably priced.

Asiago cheese is best used as a topping; if you prefer to grate parmesan cheese on top of pizzas or salads, this is a good option. It may, however, be used in pesto or pasta sauces.

Can’t locate asiago but want something with a comparable flavor and taste? See the most popular asiago cheese replacements.

Romano Cheese:

While most people use romano cheese in conjunction with parmesan, it may also be used as a substitution. It should not be confused with pecorino romano, a separate and more costly Italian cheese.

Romano cheese is also a little firmer than asiago, therefore people who favor the texture of parmesan cheese may want to replace romano.

In your recipe, grated romano may be used in place of parmesan cheese. Because the taste is intense and salty, use the same quantity of romano as you would parmesan.

Nutritional Yeast:

This plant-based replacement may give your dairy-free foods a delicious, cheesy flavor. Whether you are lactose intolerant or just searching for a simple parmesan substitute, nutritional yeast may be the way to go.

Nutritional yeast is a popular element in soups, so if your soup recipe asks for parmesan, substitute this item. It not only adds cheesy umami taste, but it may also thicken and cream your soup. It even has some health advantages!

While it is not as widespread, some individuals utilize nutritional yeast in the same manner that they would shredded parmesan cheese. It goes well on top of pasta or pizza, or it may be used to make a vegan alfredo sauce. Because nutritional yeast has a strong taste, you only need half as much as you would for parmesan.

Pecorino Romano:

In true Italian cooking, this excellent cheese is a typical replacement for parmesan. Unlike parmesan, the major component in this cheese is sheep milk rather than cow milk. This increases the fat content somewhat more than parmesan or other cow milk-based cheeses.

It may be matured for up to a year, although most pecorino romano cheeses are much younger. Nonetheless, Pecorino Romano has a salty, savory, and aged taste that is comparable to parmesan.

This cheese has a firm and flaky texture that makes it ideal for grating on top of foods or incorporating into pesto. Because of its high fat level, it also melts easily, making it excellent for alfredo sauce. Pecorino romano may be used as a 1:1 substitute for parmesan due to its comparable texture and taste.

Grana Padano:

This cheese, like Pecorino Romano, is a frequent parmesan cheese alternative in Italian cookery. It is likewise made from sheep milk, so anticipate a high fat content and substantial nutritional value.

Grana Padano is matured for at least nine months, giving it a texture and taste akin to parmesan cheese. It has a creamy, nutty taste that pairs well with pesto. It is also quite firm and flaky, like parmesan.

When substituting Grana Padano for parmesan cheese, use the same quantity as you would parmesan.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you want to know how to make the most of your parmesan cheese substitutes? Here are the answers to some of your questions:

Can I replace parmesan cheese with mozzarella?

In certain circumstances, mozzarella may be substituted for parmesan cheese. It may work for recipes where parmesan is just used as a garnish, such as pizza, baked pasta, or chicken parmesan.

However, the textures of these two types of cheese are very different. Parmesan is an extremely hard cheese, but mozzarella is one of the softest. Also, as mozzarella melts, it may become stringy and cluster together.

Parmesan cheese, on the other hand, dissolves when melted. As a result, you should avoid substituting mozzarella for parmesan in alfredo sauce or pesto.

The flavor of mozzarella is also distinct; unlike parmesan, which is aged to get its strong and nutty flavor, mozzarella is younger and so considerably more mild and creamy.

Overall, it is reasonable to argue that mozzarella is not a suitable substitute for parmesan.

Check out our selection of cheeses that are comparable to mozzarella instead.

Which parmesan cheese replacement is best for alfredo sauce?

To create the appropriate texture and taste of an alfredo sauce, use a thoroughly aged cheese. The better the cheese, the tougher and sharper it is.

So, if you’re looking for a parmesan cheese substitute for your alfredo sauce, Grana Padano is your best bet. You probably won’t notice the difference if you use it in lieu of parmesan in your alfredo sauce.

If you’re seeking for a dairy-free substitute, nutritional yeast is your best bet. This is a simple approach to give your alfredo sauce a cheese taste without adding any dairy ingredients. It may not taste exactly the same, but it can be fairly convincing.

Which parmesan cheese replacement is best for pesto?

Pesto does not need parmesan, but it gives a delightful savory taste. If you enjoy cheese in your pesto but can’t get parmesan, use Pecorino Romano. It has a distinct salty flavor that will complement your homemade pesto well.

Can you melt parmesan cheese?

You certainly can. However, the melting point will vary based on the grade and kind of parmesan cheese used.

Fresh, high-quality parmesan melts beautifully. However, most parmesan cheese sold in supermarkets has undergone extensive processing. As a consequence, melting is often more difficult.Finely ground parmesan (such as the cheap sort found in plastic canisters) is the most difficult to melt since it is excessively processed and includes fillers.

If you want to melt your parmesan cheese, obtain it whole and shred it by hand, or buy it pre-shredded rather than crushed.

Many of the parmesan alternatives on this list, such as asiago and romano, melt readily. So, if you’re searching for a meltable parmesan substitute, you may want to try one of them.

Is parmesan cheese vegetarian?

No, parmesan cheese is not often vegetarian.Rennet, which originates from the interior intestines of cows, sheep, and other animals, is often used in the production of Parmesan cheese.

Some extensively processed parmesan cheese, on the other hand, does not need rennet. Others may want to use a plant-based rennet instead. However, in most circumstances, your parmesan cheese will not be vegetarian.

Those seeking for a vegetarian substitute for parmesan might investigate nutritional yeast. This delectable plant-based substitute may give your foods the salty taste of parmesan cheese.

What is the difference between parmesan cheese and Parmigiano-Reggiano?

Parmesan and Parmigiano-Reggiano are two cheeses that are related but ultimately distinct. Parmesan is a subset of Parmigiano-Reggiano, which must adhere to rigorous guidelines.

The standards for a product to be named parmesan are rather simple. Many parmesan cheeses are matured for just 10 months. They may also include fillers and are often subjected to extensive processing.

Parmigiano-Reggiano, on the other hand, is exclusively found in a few locations of Italy. It must be matured for at least one year and cannot include fillers or other byproducts. It cannot bear the Parmigiano-Reggiano label if it does not fulfill these conditions.

Related Articles on Cheese Substitution:

  • Fontina cheese substitute
  • Manchego cheese substitute
  • Gruyere cheese substitute


What is the best non dairy Parmesan cheese substitute?

Here are a few of our favorite brands of vegan Parmesan cheese:
Dairy-Free Parmesan (Shredded) Follow Your Heart
Dairy-Free Parmesan (Grated) by Follow Your Heart
Topping: GO VEGGIE Vegan Parmesan Grated.
Topping: GO VEGGIE Vegan Soy-Free Parmesan Grated.
Parma!… Violife Like a Parmesan Wedge.
Make Your Own Vegan Parmesan Cheese.

What can be substituted for Parmesan cheese?

Dairy Pecorino is one of the best Parmesan cheese substitutes. Pecorino is similar to parmesan in appearance, but it is manufactured from sheep’s milk and has a sharper, more acidic flavor.
Cheese made from goats.
Salad with Ricotta.
Brazilian Nuts.
Flakes of nutritional yeast.

Is there a non dairy Parmesan cheese?

Violife Parmesan Cheese is a fantastic choice for vegans who desire the flavor of Parmesan cheese without the dairy. Coconut oil, rice protein, potato & rice starch, modified food starch (potato), olive extract, and vitamin B12 are among the constituents. A one-ounce serving contains 8 grams of carbohydrates.

What is non dairy Parmesan?

Perhaps not everyone is aware that Parmigiano Reggiano has no lactose, making it a lactofree cheese that is also ideal for lactose sensitive users.

What cheese is similar to Parmesan but creamier?

Piave is a cow’s milk cheese from Italy that is similar to parmesan and is recognized as parmesan’s cousin. It’s a roughly 12-month-old matured cheese recognized for its umami tastes and toasted nuttiness. It is creamier than parmesan, which tends to be sweeter.

Is Parmesan OK for dairy intolerance?

We’re come to let you know that the rumors are real! Or, more accurately, Parmesan has such a low lactose content that it does not normally bother lactose intolerant people. The more lactose a cheese has, the younger it is.

What is a healthy substitute for Parmesan cheese?

Sprinkle nutritional yeast on top of dishes that would ordinarily be topped with parmesan, or add it to sauces, soups, and dips. You normally only need half as much nutritional yeast as parmesan—just taste as you go.

What can vegetarians use instead of Parmesan?

Veggie substitute for Parmesan cheese
Grange Italian-style Hard Cheese from Twineham.
Dairy-Free Italian Hard Style Cheezly from VBites.
You may also get store versions of Italian-style hard cheeses, but check the labels to ensure they are vegetarian.

What can I use instead of Parmesan cheese in Alfredo sauce?

What are some alternatives to parmesan cheese? The most common grated cheese used in Alfredo sauce is Parmesan. Cheeses such as Parmigiano-Reggiano, Pecorino Romano, Grana Padano, Pecorino, and other hard cheeses may be utilized.

What is a cheap alternative for Parmesan cheese?

Romano Pecorino

When Parmesan isn’t available, most people will choose for this cheese. Pecorino has a similar taste and texture to Parmesan, but there are a few important distinctions. Pecorino is manufactured from sheep’s milk, which has a higher fat content than cow’s milk.

Rate this post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *